Style: Pale Ale (American)

ABV: 5.4 IBU: 33.0

97/100

Aroma:	12
Appearance:	3
Flavor:	19
Mouthfeel:	5

Wild West Smooth Criminal

What the brewers say

“Features the traditional all-star Cascade plus a few other modern hops.”

What our panel thought

“Light aromatics of tangerine, lemon, pine, black tea. Subtle hints of caramel-malt sweetness showcase the restrained bitter hop notes of pine and orange marmalade, with hints of rose petal, green tea, and lemongrass. Finish is a perfect mix of bitter and sweet.”

What our editors thought

“Lightly toasty malt with slightly herbal aroma hops. Light and toasty in the sip, if anything a bit dialed-back in bitterness and hop flavor, but the gentle approach makes it accessible.”

Review printed in: Rethinking the Classic Pale Ale (Winter 2023) (View All Issues)

Print Shelf Talker

How We Review

REVIEWS FOR YOU >

The Big Friendly Amarillo Fresh Hop

“Notes of orange, mango, pineapple, peach combine with hints of pine and garlic in the nose. A sharp bitterness that leans piney cuts through the somewhat soft malt and strips away much of the nuance. The bitterness lingers into the finish.”

Sidras Bereziartua Sagardoak Bereziartura

“Great nose: _Brett_-like goaty funk, earthy, leathery with hints of cinnamon. Dry, well-crafted with funky complexity and nice depth.”

Wild West Stone Forest IPA

Oxidized diesel-forward hop aromatics, with background tropical fruit character. Interesting juicy fruit gum, that doesn't fade after chewing it for 5 seconds, the oxidation is hard to work through, however (understandable given the journey this beer took). You really have to dig in to find the subtle hop aromatics, but when you do, you discover notes of peach, lemon, earthy pine, and a hint of diesel. If this beer was fresh on tap, its radness would be evident. A nice tea-like bitterness punctuates the flavor profile with notes of stone fruit initially that slowly fade into a more resinous bitterness that lingers into the dry, mouth-coating bitter finish. Maintains a dry character without sacrificing body. Hop bitterness is present but modern, and not overwhelming.

FRESH BEERS >

The best new craft beers available in a beer store near you. Sponsored content.

New Belgium Dominga Grapefruit

New Belgium wood cellar blender Lauren Limbach was gifted a new foeder that she aptly named Dominga—a play on the Spanish word for Sunday. She first created a mimosa-inspired golden sour called “Dominga: Goddess of Brunch.” Now we are excited to introduce the cocktail-inspired version, Dominga Grapefruit Paloma. Inspired by the classic cocktail of Mexico, Dominga packs a refreshing combo of bright grapefruit and lime flavors, along with agave and a pinch of salt.

Firestone Walker Oaktoberfest

Oaktoberfest is our oak-inspired homage to the great German tradition of Oktoberfest. We go the extra mile of maturing this beer in French oak barrels to create an amazingly smooth mouthfeel. The result is a classic German festbier with a hint of West Coast hoppiness. Grab your stein, don your lederhosen, and enjoy!

Firestone Walker Parabola ’24

Parabola is always a beast of a beer, with intense flavors of black cherry, dark chocolate, vanilla, and roast coffee—yet each annual release also bears its own subtle imprint. For this latest edition, we aged the beer for a year in 12-year Elijah Craig barrels. These coveted bourbon barrels imparted signature notes of charred oak, caramel, and cinnamon, taking the Parabola experience to new heights. Pour some out in your favorite snifter; behold the impossibly opaque color as you allow it to warm up a bit; and then let the dark magic of Parabola stun your palate with its unrivaled flavor and complexity.

Sierra Nevada Cosmic Little Thing Hazy Double IPA

For the latest in the Hazy IPA series, ride Sierra Nevada’s interstellar wave of tropical flavor in this Cosmic Little Thing, a hazy nebula glowing with Comet, Strata, and Helios hops for notes of citrus, berries, and lychee. Head into orbit with this 8 percent ABV hazy double IPA before the next Hazy IPA rotator hits. Look for Cosmic Little Thing in six-packs and 19.2 oz singles.

Firestone Walker Cosmic Crusher Juicy Imperial IPA

Out-of-this-world flavor that packs a punch—take a journey with Cosmic Crusher. “Cosmic Crusher is our crazy adventure into the realm of imperial juicy IPAs,” says brewmaster Matt Brynildson. Cosmic Crusher is built around two ultra-tropical hops—Galaxy and Strata. The result is a level of flavor, aroma, and mouthfeel that can only materialize at high strength, crossing the line into a whole new cosmos of punchy mango and pineapple character. SKUs available: 12 oz six-pack cans, 19.2 oz single serve, and Mind Haze Variety Pack.

Firestone Walker Luponic Distortion

Luponic Distortion is the Firestone Walker trailblazer that continues to break the rules, back for the first time since 2021. The classic Luponic Distortion base recipe returns with an all-new hop blend to deliver a fresh blast from the past. Brewed with a secret blend of new-age hops, the 2024 edition of Luponic Distortion turns up the volume with mind-bending flavors of lychee, peach, nectarine, and strawberry. Available exclusively in the Beer Before Glory IPA Mixed Pack.