Style: Barrel-Aged Imperial Stout

ABV: 12.0 IBU: 43.0

96/100
Aroma: 12
Appearance: 3
Flavor: 18
Mouthfeel: 5

Surly Brewing Co. Barrel-Aged Darkness

What the brewers say

Aged in rye whiskey barrels. Chocolate, vanilla, dried fruit, cherry.

What our panel thought

Aromas of bourbon, dark cherry, raisin. Soft malt complexity across the palate with a heavy sweetness. Dark-fruit notes through the retronasal. Big splash of bourbon and cherry at the finish. Some alcohol warmth at the end.

What our editors thought

The warm bourbon oak nose is concise yet rich and welcoming with a peanut-brittle undertone. The sip is instantly enveloping with rich dark chocolate and fennel notes that resolve as a slightly sweet milk-chocolate note, braced by a mild but structuring roast. Exquisitely layered and characterful.

Review printed in: Stouts for All Seasons (Oct-Nov 2019) (View All Issues)


REVIEWS FOR YOU >

Surly Brewing Company 2021 Barrel-Aged Darkness

“Compelling aroma of vanilla, dark fudge, smoke, boysenberry, anise, dried cherry, caramel, coffee. Flavor reveals sweeter hints of sherry, vanilla, caramel, turbinado. Beautifully orchestrated.”

Surly Brewing 2020 Barrel-aged Darkness

Thick molasses nose, rich chocolate cream, savory roast nuts, toasted marshmallow. Luxurious, cottony texture, like drinking taffy.

SweetWater Brewing Company Bourbon Barrel–Aged Imperial Stout

**Aroma:** “Mild bourbon, with vanilla, chocolate, light caramel, and malt roast. Dark fruit, raisins, light plum, and a touch of apple. Some light vinegar in there, too.” **Flavor:** “The sip starts with a rich flavor that’s a mix of roast, chocolate, vanilla, oak, and cherries. Dark fruits (raisin and prune), followed by the bourbon and mild smokiness. Medium alcoholic warmth, which carries through the finish. The body is thick and chewy and very smooth. It’s a nice blend of supporting players without any one stealing the show.” **Overall:** “This beer is very rich, with huge chocolate and bourbon, with strong roast and a moderate astringency that plays with the alcohol warming at the end of the sip. It has a big, thick body, and a single pint is probably as much as I could drink of this—it provided a nice platform to blend the flavors of the beer and the barrel. The flavors supported one another in a smooth and complex blend, and each sip gave more to consider, adding to the overall experience.”

FRESH BEERS >

The best new craft beers available in a beer store near you. Sponsored content.