Spices have a long history of use in beer. In fact, since the beginning of beer making some 8,000 years ago until the introduction of hops roughly in the High Middle Ages in Europe, spices both local and exotic, along with herbs, had been the dominant beer flavoring. In many Belgian beer styles, they are still popular to this day, and they are once again being used by many modern craft brewers, often for seasonal specialty beers, including Christmas and other holiday beers. During the Age of Discovery, spices became increasingly available to Europeans, who used them in both their food and their beer. Brewers in medieval times often used spices not just for their own flavor but also to cover up acidic, rancid, or medicinal off-flavors in their beer. Medieval physicians often attributed healthful qualities to spices—many of which, of course, have not stood up in the light of modern science— leading to such fanciful prescription as drinking a mug of hot spiced beer, similar to a toddy, mulled wine, or glögg, as an antidote to the plague.
Spices mainly used for bittering in beer and for balancing its malt aroma were bay leaf, juniper, and such seeds of the umbel family (Apiaceae) as anise, caraway, coriander, dill, and fennel. Carrot and parsley belong to this group as well. These seeds not only taste bitter but also impart significant aromas and anise/coriander/licorice flavors. Other spices add a chili-like sharpness to the brew. These include chili peppers, black and green peppers, ginger, quassia, and grains of paradise. Next is the group of “true” spices, each with its own unique flavor. There is allspice, cardamom, cinnamon, clove, licorice, mace/nutmeg, and star anise, as well as the zest of different citrus fruits. Many of these spices have been and still are particular favorites for Christmas cooking, baking, and beer making. Finally, a few nontraditional beer flavorings have been used by many brewers. Vanilla, for example, has become common, whereas saffron is perhaps considered more experimental.
There is some controversy among brewers about the proper techniques for using spices in beer. Some hold that spices should be added only sparingly and must not overpower the flavors put into the beer by malt, hops, and yeast. Others, however, prefer a less nuanced approach and prefer to challenge traditional notions of beer flavor. This often means that a spice that is traditional for a particular kind of beer, such as Curaçao orange peel in Belgian wit, may migrate to a beer style where it has never been used before. In the United States, the most prevalent spiced beers are seasonal pumpkin ales, which are popular in the autumn and winter months. Although most of these beers do contain pumpkin, the flavors are often driven by combinations of cinnamon, allspice, nutmeg, ginger, vanilla, and other spices. The goal is to mimic the aroma and flavor of the traditional American pumpkin pie, which is consumed almost exclusively during the winter holiday season. Aside from Belgium, where spices are used less than is often supposed, brewing with spices is currently seen most frequently among craft brewers in the United States, Denmark, and the UK, with Italian craft brewers swiftly following.
Bibliography
Spices and Their Uses in Beer
Common name |
Scientific name |
Part used |
Comment |
Use (examples) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Allspice |
Pimenta dioica |
Seed |
Bitterness, significant aroma, healthy, beer preservative |
Christmas beers, medieval medicinal beers |
Anise |
Pimpinella anisum |
Seed |
Adds a spicy and anise-like bitterness during the boil |
Historical beer bittering |
Bay leaf |
Laurus nobilis |
Leaf |
Bitterness, significant aroma, healthy, beer preservative |
Recent experimental brewing |
Caraway |
Carum carvi |
Seed |
Adds a spicy and anise-like bitterness during the boil |
Historical beer bittering |
Cardamom |
Elettaria cardamomum |
Seed |
Powerfully aromatic, ginger family |
Christmas beers, medieval medicinal beers |
Chili pepper |
Capsicum spp. |
Fruit |
Both vegetal flavor and capsaicin heat |
Original porter, experimental brewing |
Cinnamon |
Cinnamomum verum |
Bark |
Popular, but often is actually cassia bark |
Pumpkin ales and Christmas beers, medieval medicinal beers |
Citrus |
Citrus spp. |
Peel |
Lemon peel; sweet, canned orange peel; Curaçao |
Belgian-style ales, particularly witbier |
Clove |
Syzygium aromaticum |
Flower bud |
Very powerful, best used sparingly |
Pumpkin ales and Christmas beers |
Coriander |
Coriandrum sativum |
Seed |
Widely used |
Medieval medicinal beers Belgium wit |
Dill |
Anethum graveolens |
Seed |
Adds a spicy and anise-like bitterness during the boil |
Historical beer bittering |
Fennel |
Foeniculum vulgare |
Seed |
Adds a spicy and anise-like bitterness during the boil |
Historical beer bittering |
Ginger |
Zingiber officinale |
Root |
Highly aromatic |
Original porter, medieval medicinal beers |
Grains of paradise |
Aframomum melegueta |
Seed |
Pepper-like spice with notes of citrus and pine; once believed to be an aphrodisiac |
Old English ales, abandoned in the 17th century by law, experimental brewing |
Juniper |
Juniperus communis |
Berry |
Used in the mash or boil |
Historical Scandinavian brewing, such as Finnish Sahti, for which boughs, too, are used in the mash |
Licorice |
Glycyrrhiza glabra |
Root |
Bitter, medicinal |
Original porter and stout |
Mace |
Myristica fragrans |
Fruit/aril |
A sophisticated and delicious alternative to nutmeg |
Holiday beers |
Nutmeg |
Myristica fragrans |
Fruit/nut |
Christmas beers, medieval medicinal beers, experimental brewing |
|
Parsley |
Petroselinum crispum |
Seed |
Adds a spicy and anise- like bitterness during the boil |
Historical beer bittering |
Pepper |
Piper nigrum |
Seed |
Highly fragrant, adds heat if concentrated |
Experimental brewing, medieval medicinal beers |
Quassia |
Quassia amara |
Wood |
Quinine-like |
Historical beer bittering |
Saffron |
Crocus sativus |
Style/stigma |
Very expensive, strong savory flavor |
Experimental brewing |
Star anise |
Illicium verum |
Seed |
Adds a spicy and anise- like bitterness during the boil |
Experimental brewing, Christmas beers |
Vanilla |
Vanilla planifolia |
Fruit |
Widely used |
Holiday beers, porters |