Style: Cider

ABV: 5.0

94/100
Aroma: 12
Appearance: 3
Flavor: 18
Mouthfeel: 4

Samuel Smith Old Brewery Organic Cider

What the brewers say

“A medium dry cider with brilliant straw color, light body, clean apple flavor, and a gentle apple blossom finish. Made at a small, independent brewery, the oldest brewery in Yorkshire.”

What our panel thought

Aroma: “A big blend of red and green apples with light sugar, a bit of alcohol, and low spicy yeast elements. It’s very bright with light hints of grape and floral notes. Slight chardonnay-like fermenta- tion esters and a touch of malic acidity.”

Flavor: “Super clean fermentation char- acteristics and big apple flavors lead to a medium-dry slightly tannic finish with lingering tart/sour notes. Slightly bitter in the finish, but not off-putting. Appropriate low alcohol warming and moderately low carbonation mitigates the bitterness. Light apple, fruity, with a touch of that grape from the nose.”

Overall: “Full-flavored cider with big apple flavors that still tastes ‘crushable.’ Simple and straightforward, the apple is so clear and obvious, but finishes crisp with a cleansing carbonation and acidity. Strong apple aroma and other esters make this a pleasant drink that you can drink for some time.”

What our editors thought


REVIEWS FOR YOU >

Samuel Smith's Organic Cider

“Great apple presentation throughout. A bit sweet on balance, lingers on the tongue with light floral spicy notes. Clean, bright, and pleasingly effervescent. Simple apple sweetness with just a touch of tannins. Very accessible and drinkable.”

Angry Orchard Cider Company Muse

**Aroma:** “Raw apple juice and sweet apple-blossom notes on the nose are backed up with light peach/almond, red caramel apple, plum, cotton candy, and red wine notes.” **Flavor:** “Red Delicious abounds. There’s a noticeable alcohol heat and nice tart acidity. Simple apple sweetness isn’t cloying, and the esters really push through—grape, peach, a little pine- apple. Light marzipan with a moderate tartness to balance, but definitely leans sweet. A touch of oaky astringency adds depth and interest. Finishes soft with a very mild touch of alcohol. Strong carbonation is very effervescent.” **Overall:** “Sweet and fairly simple apple with an interesting fermentation charac- ter and complexity from layers of apple and dark fruits expressing throughout. Tannic red wine-like character is a very pleasant counterpoint to the red apple character.”

Samuel Smith's Brewery Apricot Ale

__Aroma:__ “Dried apricot, red fruit, cherries, raspberry. Perfumy and floral with moderate apricot sweetness. It almost smells fuzzy. Maybe a bit of sweet breadiness in the background. Some sour notes.” __Flavor:__ “Apricot, peach, cherry, raspberry. Far sweeter than expected, without the tartness common to apricot beers. Finishes with a drying sensation and a touch of tartness, but the sweetness lingers at the back of the palate. Sweet apricot juice taste jumps out and overwhelms the underlying beer. Little hops bitterness or malt qualities make this straightforward.” __Overall:__ “The fruit character is nice, but the sweetness is confusing and makes me think that the beer was back-sweetened. The fruit balance is about right, but it is too close to being cloying to drink much of it. I miss the supporting beer qualities.”

FRESH BEERS >

The best new craft beers available in a beer store near you. Sponsored content.