Surly Bender
What the brewers say
“This brown ale begins crisp and lightly hoppy, complemented by the velvety sleekness oats deliver. Belgian and British malts usher in cascades of cocoa, bitter-coffee, caramel, and hints of vanilla and cream.”
What our panel thought
Aroma: “The aroma changes as it warms. Toasty malt up front with some honey and a bit of umami reminiscent of fish sauce. As it warms, blackberry and other dark-fruit esters come out. Kind of a subdued nose overall, but the cherry ester dominates everything. Deep earthy, almost mushroom-like aroma with a touch of toast. Smells like mushroom-vegetable-barley soup.”
Flavor: “Moderate sweet with moderate bitterness in the finish. Retronasal—more umami and blackberry and cranberry. Cherry and burnt toast with a touch of chocolate. Ester-forward with the malt playing second fiddle.”
Overall: “A decent American Brown that stays between the lines and delivers what it promises, but nothing more. An easy-drinking brown ale with a firm platform of caramel malts, but just a bit thin.”