Style: American Barleywine

ABV: 11.2 IBU: 80.0

94/100
Aroma: 11
Appearance: 3
Flavor: 20
Mouthfeel: 4

Stone Brewing Old Guardian Barley Wine

What the brewers say

“A rich, slightly sweet, caramel-hued ale infused with assertive bitterness and bright hops notes, culminating in a pleasing dryness. While it will evolve with age, the flavor will challenge your ability to wait to drink it.”

What our panel thought

Aroma: “Citrus orange and slight pine accompany big caramel, toffee, and plum, with moderate cherry and light alcohol warmth. There’s almost some graham cracker.”

Flavor: “A nice caramel, toasty, nutty sweetness carries through from start to finish of the sip and blends well with the juicy orange and slight grapefruit hops character. Alcohol warmth is present and carries through in the finish along with some peppery notes.”

Overall: “This barleywine with big malt and strong alcohol notes was put together well. The malt character and hops worked, and the beer was big but not at the expense of drinkability. The malty component is quite nice and balanced with moderate American hops. The malt and hops profiles are straightforward with nice caramel malt and piney bitterness.”

What our editors thought

Review printed in: Big Beers (December 2015-January 2016) (View All Issues)


REVIEWS FOR YOU >

New Image Brewing Co 9505

“Enticing cinnamon, allspice, clove, dark chocolate, sweet raisin notes yield a remarkable nose. The flavor also delights with an almost Mexican hot-chocolate character. Smooth alcohol and a long rich finish. Outstanding!”

LIC Beer Project Barley Wine

Aroma: “It started off mild and built into a nice combination of malt aromas that include the requisite nutty, caramel, toffee, and light roast. The hops are woody and spicy, and there’s alcohol evident, in a slightly sweet way.” Flavor: “This shows signs of great aging with sherry and dates coming on strong and complemented by wet black malt, roast, earthy hops, medium bitterness, lots of alcohol, and finishing with a dessert-wine sweetness that stops just short of cloying. Throughout, there’s rich layers of chocolate, plums, dates, dried cherry, and other assorted fruits.” Overall: “It’s a big, complex English-style barley wine with a sweet finish—a great beer to share with friends but one that might be harder to finish alone. It seems prime for aging, but the rich layers of malt and ester flavors offer no reason to wait. It’s not a subtle beer and doesn’t try to hide its strength. This is an after dinner, around the fireplace sipper.”

AleSmith Brewing Company Old Numbskull

**Aroma:** “Nice malt sweetness with hints of orange, lemon, and pine. Bready and sweet malt aroma.” **Flavor:** “Bright and juicy hops avors push forward over moderate caramel sweetness and yeast esters that almost venture into Belgian-style bubble gum territory. A slight nuttiness adds an earthy foil against sweet orange and grapefruit citrus and lingers into the aftertaste with only a slight alcohol heat and a smidgen of phenolic bitterness.” **Overall:** “An enjoyable beer that starts off fruity with strong citrus hops char- acter over a light and sweet malt base. The phenolic component was slightly off-putting and the hops aroma wasn’t quite as assertive as hoped for, but it was earthy, well-grounded, and very drinkable as an American barleywine.

FRESH BEERS >

The best new craft beers available in a beer store near you. Sponsored content.