Allagash Brewing Co. Windfall
What the brewers say
Sour wild ale fermented with Brettanomyces and aged on locally grown peaches."
What our panel thought
"Aroma of Cheerios and light fruit, not distinctly peaches. Low background funk. The fruit comes through in the flavor—peaches followed by a light citrus acidity. Grainy aftertaste echoes the aroma. Drying tannins in the finish."
What our editors thought
"A near-perfect peach nose feels equal parts earthy, sweet, perfumey, subtle, and punchy. Bright peach character follows through the sip with a mild acidity and dry ever-so-faintly-bitter finish."