Stan Hieronymus shares the three keys to brewing successfully with wet hops and the four “rules of hops” that you should understand.
Trevor Holmes, head brewer at Wadworth Brewery in the south of England, surely was not the first to add freshly picked hops to a batch of beer—that likely happened hundreds, maybe even thousands, of years before Holmes made the first batch of Malt ‘n’ Hops in 1992. However, his beer begat the first Sierra Nevada Harvest Ale in 1996, which in turn begat hundreds of beers variously described as wet hopped or fresh hopped.
The two aren’t necessarily the same. Brewers sometimes describe hops right out of a drying kiln as fresh, so “fresh-hops” beers may be brewed with either dried hops or unkilned hops. Wet hops are never kilned. The difference matters in the brewing kettle just as much as in the glass.
The first time Holmes brewed Malt ‘n’ Hops, he expected the 100-barrel batch to last a month. It sold out in a week. The late Michael Jackson described it as having “a surge of cleansing, refreshing, resiny, almost orange-zest flavors; and, finally, an astonishingly late, long finish of fresh, appetite-arousing bitterness.” Sierra Nevada Brewmaster Steve Dresler learned about the beer secondhand, from Gerard Lemmens, a native of England who worked for an American hops broker at the time. Dresler was otherwise left to his own devices, but these days the path is better marked. There are three keys to brewing successfully with wet hops and four “rules of hops” that you should understand.
What You Really Need to Know
» Wet hops truly are wet.
Water accounts for about 80 percent of the weight of unkilned hops cones and 10 percent of dried hops. That’s why most brewers add five to eight times, measured by weight, more wet hops than they would dry. The wet hops will take up more room in the kettle, not five times more, but enough to consider reducing the batch size. They’ll also add water that needs to be considered when calculating final gravities. To brew HopTime Harvest Ale, Vinnie Cilurzo at Russian River Brewing makes three hops additions: at the beginning of a 90-minute boil, with 30 minutes to go, and at the end. He knows he’s on track to hit his target gravity when the reading with 30 minutes to go matches his final target because the last two hops additions will contain as much moisture as will evaporate in 30 minutes.
» Fresh matters.
Because cones contain such a high percentage of water, they literally begin to rot shortly after they are picked, which is why farmers transport them directly from the field to drying kilns. They generally must be dried or added to a batch of beer within 24 to 48 hours after they are picked. Brewers in the Northwest, located close to the farms where most of America’s hops are grown, often dispatch their own trucks to collect freshly harvested hops. Back at the brewery, another crew will start the mash based upon when they expect the hops to arrive. Brewers elsewhere may have hops shipped overnight. YCH HOPS expects to sell about 20 tons of “Green Hops” during the 2015 harvest, shipping them across the United States, including to Alaska and Hawaii.
The resurgence in hops growing outside the Northwest has made it easier for commercial brewers and homebrewers to find locally grown fresh hops. And of course, some commercial brewers and homebrewers simply grow their own.
» It is possible to use too much.
There’s a point of saturation at which “grassy” is no longer a positive attribute, and the experience becomes more like chewing on green leaves. “I really want the aroma. The freshness is what it’s about,” Sierra Nevada’s Dresler says. “If you try to drive up the bitterness [by adding more wet hops], you’ll start to get those grassy notes, chlorophylly.” That’s one reason to consider using dried hops, including in pellet form, for the bittering addition. It not only reduces the hops load in the kettle, but it also provides a known source of alpha acids. Another reason to use dry hops for bittering is that home growers can only guess how much bitterness the hops from their backyards may add.
Four “Rules of Hops”
» Hops Chemistry before the Kettle
The aromas and flavors from wet hops that brewers covet are products of essential oils that increase dramatically throughout the weeks before harvest and will continue to change even after hops are dried and stored in bales. During the 2013 harvest, Sierra Nevada measured the essential oil content of early harvested Cascade hops at 0.3–0.7 percent, while hops picked three to four days later contained 0.7–1 percent and smelled more floral. Cascade picked at mid-harvest had 1–1.5 percent oils, and mid- to late-harvest hops 1.5–2 percent. Those were more floral, with citrus and emerging pine notes. Cascades picked two and a half weeks after the first hops had up to 3 percent oil. At their best, they had pleasant herbal and woody aromas but sometimes less pleasant onion and garlic character.
Research at Oregon State University has shown that not only does the amount of oil change, but so does the composition. Unfortunately, there are no studies comparing the differences between wet hops and those that have been kilned. “This is not a scientific exploration of brewing,” says Ninkasi Brewing Cofounder Jamie Floyd, who brews multiple wet-hops beers each harvest. “Where’s the economic benefit of analyzing a beer made once a year?”
» Hops Chemistry in the Kettle
Boiling triggers many of hops’ positive attributes, but it also removes oil. Brewers concerned with adding a known amount of bitterness to beer may choose to use dried hops with measured alpha acids during the boil. Those concerned with preserving oils—and that is much of the point of wet-hopped beers—should remember that a study in Japan found that boiling only 10 minutes drives off half of valuable compounds such as linalool and gernaniol. That’s why many brewers choose to add wet hops only at flameout or in a hops stand (whirlpool hopping).
» Hops Chemistry during Fermentation and Dry Hopping
Hops scientists agree that more research is needed on the biotransformations of hops compounds that occur in the presence of yeast, but recent studies prove that new ones are certainly created. That’s another reason to expect the aromas in wet-hopped beers to differ from those made with kilned hops and also why brewers should not expect a wet-hopped beer to smell just like hops picked directly off the bine. “When I taste it the first 12 or 24 hours [into fermentation], all I get is chlorophyll,” says Jeremy Marshall at Lagunitas Brewing. “The first time we made [a wet-hopped beer], it tasted like a cigar. I almost dropped a batch because of the cigar taste. Then it starts to open up; the oils go through.”
» Hops Chemistry in the Package
John Harris at Ecliptic Brewing in Portland, Oregon, does not favor bottling fresh-hopped beers. “I think they fall apart too fast to put them in the bottle. In a month they are a different beer,” he says. However, there is no reason that the aromas from wet-hopped beers would be any more ephemeral than any other hops aromas. Tom Nielsen, manager of Raw Material Development and Quality at Sierra Nevada, points out that poor oxygen control in the bottling process will injure any hoppy beer and that crown liners may scalp aroma. However, he wrote in an email, “Our harvest ales hold up exceedingly well in the bottle—probably some of the best storing beer we make.”
Because they taste fresh.